Overview
Two casting processes, two cost curves
Die casting uses a steel mold and high pressure. Sand casting uses a sand mold that is destroyed with each part. The tooling and volume economics are completely different.
For a complex housing at thousands of pieces per year, die casting usually wins. For a large, low-volume or prototype casting, sand casting often avoids the tooling bill.
Comparison
Side by side
| Consideration | Die casting | Sand casting |
|---|---|---|
| Tooling | Steel mold; higher cost | Pattern and sand; lower cost |
| Volume | Justifies tooling at repeat volume | Works at low volume and one-offs |
| Tolerance | Tighter, more repeatable | Looser; more machining stock |
| Surface | Smooth, fine detail | Rougher, more texture |
| Wall thickness | Thin walls possible | Thicker walls typical |
| Porosity | Process-dependent; controlled by design | Often higher; can be managed |
| Best for | Housings, covers, structural parts at volume | Large parts, low volume, prototypes |
Die casting
When die casting wins
Complex geometry, thin walls, integrated bosses and a repeat annual volume. The tooling cost is amortized over the parts, and the cycle time is short.
It also gives a better as-cast surface, which can reduce finishing cost on visible parts.
- Repeat volume
- Complex geometry
- Thin walls
- Good as-cast surface
- Secondary machining planned
- Tooling budget available
Sand casting
When sand casting wins
Large parts, low volume, prototypes or a design that may still change. The pattern cost is much lower, and the process tolerates a simpler tool.
The trade-off is more machining stock, a rougher surface and often more porosity. If the part is structural or must hold pressure, the design and inspection plan have to account for that.
- Low volume
- Large size
- Design not frozen
- Machining capacity available
- Surface not cosmetic
- Porosity risk understood